Reviving Sail-Powered Shipping: A Dream or a Distant Reality?
Written on
The Allure of Wind Power in Shipping
The idea of sail-powered vessels evokes a sense of nostalgia, yet the practicalities of modern shipping challenge this romantic notion. As we transition towards electrifying various industries, shipping remains one of the few sectors where direct electrification isn't straightforward.
Currently, the shipping industry is on the verge of a transformation. As reliance on fossil fuels decreases, it's expected that bulk shipping volumes will decline significantly. Battery power will dominate inland and short-sea shipping, but an estimated 70 million tons of liquid or gaseous fuels will still be necessary each year. So, what will replace traditional fuels?
A decade-long exploration reveals that companies like A.P. Moller Maersk, once the largest container shipping entity globally, are investing in green methanol. Meanwhile, the ammonia sector is advocating for its carbon-neutral product as the preferred fuel. Both options have their strengths and weaknesses, and they are already produced in substantial quantities, making them viable candidates for the future of shipping.
Other alternatives, such as liquid hydrogen, are being considered, though they face skepticism from many shipping companies. Organizations like the International Council on Clean Transportation view hydrogen as a significant option, despite its actual applicability being uncertain.
Interestingly, both green methanol and ammonia primarily derive from green hydrogen, indicating that companies like Maersk are indirectly betting on hydrogen, albeit in more manageable forms. Additionally, biofuels are gaining traction, with biodiesel currently being the most utilized alternative fuel in maritime transport. With millions of tons already in use, biofuels are expected to play a crucial role, even as ground transportation shifts to electric solutions.
There are also innovative attempts to harness wind energy in shipping once more. A few companies have experimented with fabric parafoils—akin to steerable parachutes—attached to the bows of ships to utilize favorable winds. This year, a collaboration between a major bulk shipping firm and an America's Cup offshoot tested two 37.5-meter folding rigid sails.
While the romantic idea of sailing ships is captivating, it encounters the reality of modern shipping needs, such as the extensive containerization and the towering cranes essential for loading and unloading cargo. For instance, the Marie Maersk, currently navigating the Indian Ocean, can stack containers up to 21 tiers high. The integration of sails would necessitate innovative solutions to accommodate these towering stacks while in port.
Innovative Wind Solutions
Parafoils are likely the most practical wind energy solution for container ships. They can be designed to launch, furl, and fly autonomously, although they come with potential failure scenarios. Even under optimal conditions, these parafoils could contribute to a modest reduction in fuel consumption during specific legs of a journey.
Rigid sails, however, face more stringent challenges. They must be able to fold flat to avoid interference with loading operations and low bridges, which limits their feasibility to specific types of vessels—primarily bulk carriers and roll-on/roll-off ships. For instance, the Höegh Target, a tall vessel with multiple decks, poses challenges for sail integration.
The Pyxis Ocean, another bulk carrier, was equipped with rigid sails this year, allowing for wind capture while maintaining the required height clearance for bridges. However, the complexities involved in managing these sails mean they are unlikely to become widespread in the industry.
Even more experimental is the use of Magnus effect rotors, which could potentially provide propulsion through rotation. However, the challenges of integration and the limited vessel types make this a less likely solution.
Wind energy's application in inland shipping is even more restricted, given the numerous bridges and unpredictable wind patterns. Moreover, the business model presents hurdles; the financial burden of sail installation often falls on shipowners, while the operational benefits go to the charterers.
Ultimately, the potential of sails to significantly impact global shipping fuel consumption is minimal. Parafoils may emerge as a more viable option due to lower costs and technical simplicity, yet wind power alone isn't anticipated to be a substantial contributor to maritime decarbonization.
The current global fleet comprises approximately 50,000 to 60,000 cargo vessels. Despite over a century of development in wind energy technology, only a handful of larger cargo ships are equipped with sails today. They evoke fascination but have not made a significant impact on energy consumption.
In conclusion, while the allure of alternative energy sources in freight shipping is compelling, many options have been set aside for various reasons. Future discussions will delve into the specific gases and liquids under consideration, starting with hydrogen. Stay tuned!
This video explores the future sailing plans of a prominent shipping company, revealing insights into the potential for wind-powered vessels.
In this video, the crew discusses their most significant navigational error to date while sailing around Britain, shedding light on the realities of maritime challenges.